-- ============================================================================== -- U.S. SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION (SEC) -- DIVISION OF ENFORCEMENT // FORENSIC LITIGATION UNIT -- ============================================================================== -- CASE NAME: In the Matter of OpenAI Group PBC & OpenAI Foundation -- CASE NO: 5:26-cv-07078-EJD (N.D. Cal.) -- EXHIBIT ID: SEC WHISTLEBLOWER NO. 17684-273-411-436 // SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT D -- TITLE: Forensic SQL Query Sheet for Communication Timelines & Exfiltration -- PURPOSE: Pre-compiled Relational JOINs for Automated Trial Exhibits -- DATE: August 26, 2026 -- ============================================================================== -- ============================================================================== -- EXHIBIT A: THE COVERT COMMUNICATION TIMELINE (LINE / SIGNAL PROTOCOL) -- LEGAL THEORY: Admissible under FRE 801(d)(2)(E) (Co-conspirator Statements) -- and FRE 1006 (Summaries of Voluminous Digital Records). -- DESCRIPTION: Restructures communication metadata between Chang Liu and Alyssa -- Peng to show the parallel flow of recruitment and coordination. -- ============================================================================== .headers on .mode column .width 35 25 25 15 15 15 15 SELECT (e_sender.first_name || ' ' || e_sender.last_name) AS Sender, e_sender.current_openai_title AS Sender_Corporate_Role, ec.recipient_name AS Recipient, ec.platform_name AS Platform, ec.message_count AS Total_Messages, DATETIME(ec.earliest_message_timestamp) AS Earliest_Contact, DATETIME(ec.latest_message_timestamp) AS Latest_Contact, -- Calculate active communication span in days ROUND(JULIANDAY(ec.latest_message_timestamp) - JULIANDAY(ec.earliest_message_timestamp), 2) AS Active_Span_Days, -- Highlight spoliation indicators (self-delete flags) CASE WHEN ec.self_delete_timer_seconds > 0 THEN '⚠️ HIGH RISK (Spoliation Enabled)' ELSE 'STANDARD' END AS Evidence_Spoliation_Risk FROM encrypted_channels ec JOIN employees e_sender ON ec.sender_employee_id = e_sender.employee_id -- Filter specifically for communication loops containing Liu and Peng WHERE (e_sender.employee_id = 'EMP_LIU_01' AND ec.recipient_name LIKE '%Peng%') OR (e_sender.employee_id = 'EMP_PENG_01' AND ec.recipient_name LIKE '%Liu%') ORDER BY ec.earliest_message_timestamp ASC; -- ============================================================================== -- EXHIBIT B: EXFILTRATION & NETWORK STORAGE INTRUSION LOG (THE FORENSIC TRAIL) -- LEGAL THEORY: Admissible under FRE 803(6) (Records of Regularly Conducted Activity) -- and authenticated under FRE 901(b)(9) (System Process / Output). -- DESCRIPTION: Combines Chang Liu''s unauthorized network folder accesses with -- unreturned device MAC addresses to map the stolen blueprint categories. -- ============================================================================== .width 20 20 25 35 25 18 12 SELECT (e.first_name || ' ' || e.last_name) AS Exfiltrator, e.former_apple_title AS Former_Apple_Role, d.device_type AS Access_Device, f.network_storage_path AS Unauthorized_Path_Accessed, DATETIME(f.intrusion_timestamp) AS Hack_Timestamp, f.exfiltrated_blueprint_category AS Blueprint_Category, -- Convert bytes to Megabytes for clean presentation PRINTF('%.2f MB', CAST(f.bytes_downloaded AS REAL) / (1024 * 1024)) AS Payload_Size, CASE WHEN f.authentication_vulnerability_used = 1 THEN '❌ Backdoor Used' ELSE 'Direct Credential' END AS Access_Method FROM forensic_logs f JOIN employees e ON f.employee_id = e.employee_id JOIN devices d ON f.device_id = d.device_id WHERE e.employee_id IN ('EMP_LIU_01', 'EMP_PENG_01') ORDER BY f.intrusion_timestamp ASC; -- ============================================================================== -- EXHIBIT C: RULE 10b-5 VALUE-PUMP TIMING MATRIX (THE HACK-TO-VALUATION LOOP) -- LEGAL THEORY: Establishes materiality of omissions under SEC Rule 10b-5 by -- proving that funding commitments occurred during active theft. -- DESCRIPTION: Correlates the exact timestamps of database intrusions with the -- closing schedules of OpenAI''s multi-billion dollar private capital rounds. -- ============================================================================== .width 20 25 22 25 20 18 SELECT DATETIME(f.intrusion_timestamp) AS Exfiltration_Date, (e.first_name || ' ' || e.last_name) AS Actor, f.exfiltrated_blueprint_category AS Misappropriated_IP, sm.targeted_entity AS Funding_Participant, -- Format capital round valuation in Billions PRINTF('$%.1f Billion', CAST(sm.associated_capital_round_value AS REAL) / 1000) AS Round_Valuation, sm.subpoena_status AS Subpoena_Posture, -- Days between exfiltration and funding round close CAST(JULIANDAY(sm.transaction_close_date) - JULIANDAY(f.intrusion_timestamp) AS INTEGER) AS Days_Before_Close FROM forensic_logs f JOIN employees e ON f.employee_id = e.employee_id CROSS JOIN subpoena_matches sm -- Temporal constraint: Link exfiltrations that occurred up to 60 days prior to capital round closure WHERE f.intrusion_timestamp BETWEEN DATE(sm.transaction_close_date, '-60 days') AND sm.transaction_close_date AND e.employee_id IN ('EMP_LIU_01', 'EMP_PENG_01') ORDER BY sm.transaction_close_date ASC, f.intrusion_timestamp ASC; -- ============================================================================== -- EXHIBIT D: COMPREHENSIVE RECRUIT REVENUE PIPELINE (THE TALENT SIPHON IMPACT) -- LEGAL THEORY: Quantifies damages under the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) -- by illustrating the scale of head-count exfiltration. -- DESCRIPTION: Pulls a dynamic roster of poached employees, mapping their transition -- from specific Apple divisions directly into Jony Ive''s io Products PBC. -- ============================================================================== .width 25 30 25 30 15 12 SELECT (e.first_name || ' ' || e.last_name) AS Employee_Name, e.former_apple_title AS Former_Apple_Role, e.former_apple_division AS Exited_Apple_Division, e.current_openai_title AS Assigned_OpenAI_Role, e.openai_onboarding_date AS Onboarding_Date, -- Flag if they are named in the primary trade secret complaints CASE WHEN e.is_named_defendant = 1 THEN 'YES (Target)' ELSE 'NO' END AS Named_Defendant, -- Track associated device secure hash COALESCE(d.forensic_image_hash, 'No Image (Spoliation Risk)') AS Forensic_Image_Hash FROM employees e LEFT JOIN devices d ON e.employee_id = d.employee_id WHERE e.current_openai_division LIKE '%io Products%' OR e.current_openai_division LIKE '%Consumer Devices%' ORDER BY e.openai_onboarding_date ASC;